When I thought about Number 3: Try a recipe that’s always intimidated me, on the 29 in 29 for 29 list, all kinds of ambitions came to mind. Though I love cooking and can really get into it at times, there are no less than a million things about it that intimidate me. I mean, terms like reduction and Chitarra and estouffade are enough to send me into complete panic. I have a friend that makes these beautiful, elaborate cakes with fondant icing or sugary silk-like veils and watching her do it both amazes me and makes me want to run away in fright. People, I have never even fried chicken, please don’t ask me to use tools with names I cannot even pronounce.
But there is one recipe, or meal, rather, that I’ve always wanted to be able to make. Not because it’s terribly complicated or a huge accomplishment, but rather, when I think of food that I want to make, that I want share with people, this is the thing that always comes to mind: Chicken Noodle Soup.
So common. So not a big deal. So nothing I’ve ever had a clue as to how to make. This is why I chose it. I wanted to make my own noodles, create my own broth, cook the chicken, chop the vegetables, all of it. I knew I needed a little guidance, though, if not a recipe. I called Uncle Joe, because he is one of the cooks in the family. And then it got interesting.
In 1983, Uncle Joe’s grandmother, Serena, came to visit him here in Colorado. She drove all the way from Indiana, and do you know what she brought with her? Her Chicken Noodle Soup recipe. But not purposely, it’s because Grandma Serena brought her recipes with her everywhere— they were all in her head.
Knowing this, Uncle Joe took the time to take notes when Grandma Serena made her Chicken Noodle Soup. Step by step, he followed her around the kitchen while she prepared a recipe from scratch that had been in her head for decades.
And do you know, since that day back in 1983, Uncle Joe had never attempted to recreate that recipe? Not once. Apparently, he’s thought of it often in the last 25 years, but until my phone call, he’d never gotten around to making it. I realize this is only terribly ironic for Uncle Joe and me, but still, what are the odds? The one recipe I’ve always wanted to make was also the one he’d been waiting 25 years to recreate.
So it was settled. With the help of Uncle Joe’s sister, we’d recreate Chicken Noodle Soup circa 1983 via Grandma Serena’s portable recipe index. Kitchen magic was inevitable.

We started with noodles. This was the “big deal” portion in my mind. The homemade noodles are the most important part, if you ask me.

And I took pictures. (And poured drinks, which is the OTHER reason I like cooking with Uncle Joe.)

And then I finally helped a little, and rolled out the dough. We rolled it out into a really thin, flat sheet of beautiful dough. You’ll see that later.

While the dough dried (set?) a little, we headed out to the garden. Yet another reason to hang out with Uncle Joe: a pretty great garden. With giant pumpkins:

And cauliflower:

And beets:

And the one thing I was absolutely insistent on adding to MY chicken soup, carrots:

I’m sorry to gloat here, but how awesome is that? I just went right outside and picked carrots from the ground that in less than an hour after I pulled them up, would be IN MY SOUP. I’m amazed, still.

I should also mention that we’d put the chicken in to cook before we went out to the garden. It boiled in the pot for like an hour with bullion and celery and onions, and that’s really all I know about that. Because you may remember how I feel about handling raw meat, so Uncle Joe took care of that. THANK YOU, Uncle Joe. I am just not sure I’ll ever be ready for a whole chicken.
But I did cut (slice?) the noodles! Ohhhhhh, ahhhhhh! And I think I did a pretty good job with that:

We drained the broth from the chicken, then added the noodles, the chicken (prepared and chopped by, hey, not me!), and, of course, the carrots. I think a few onions made it in, too.



Judging by looks alone, I felt pretty good about our creation. It smelled like comfort and home, so I figured we couldn’t go wrong from there.

The ultimate test, though, was the rest of the family. My aunt, she’s not the harsh critic. But my two cousins, 18 and 20, are the ultimate judges. Not because of their fine culinary tastes or their finicky palates, but rather if you can’t get 18 and 20-year-old guys to eat food you made, something is seriously wrong with that food.
But it turned out, they did like it. Loved it, in fact. Apparently one of them had his leftovers for breakfast the next morning, which I’m guessing is slightly better than cold pizza when you’re in college. Or ever.

This was a great cooking experience for me. No longer am I intimidated by making my own noodles or attempting to make a simple recipe from simple ingredients. It is not always about fabulous technique or intimidating words. (Even if someone adds pepper—no idea what was going on there).
And though I didn’t do this all on my own, I wouldn’t have had it any other way.